Road & Track Comparison Test

Nostalgia is a strong point. It pervades so a lot of the zeitgeist, with Television reboots obtaining cranked out at an almost alarming level, and vinyl report revenue topping $1 billion for the initially time considering that 1986. Vehicle fanatics are a particularly nostalgic bunch just look at the values of the cars Gen X and Millennials observed as icons. This cultural pressure has observed a variety of good nameplates revived, like the Toyota Supra, or reinvigorated with an eye in direction of past glories, as is the scenario with the new Nissan Z.

Z vs. Supra is by no suggests a perennial battle like Mustang vs. Camaro, though the 300ZX and Supra went just after the type searching for a rapidly, technologically state-of-the-art, sporting activities-GT via the Eighties and Nineties. Now, these two in shape the a lot more common sports activities motor vehicle mold: 6-cylinder engines underneath a extensive hood, two seats in the middle, pushed wheels at the back.

Rate Comparison

This comparison exam was evident past any nostalgic connections. The Nissan Z expenditures $51,015 in “Efficiency” guise, tends to make 400 hp and 350 lb-ft from a twin-turbo V-6 and weighs 3507 pounds. The Supra 3. starts at $52,500, can make 382 hp and 368 lb-ft from a solitary-turbo straight-six, and weighs 3347 lbs ..

(We are simplifying things a little bit, as the foundation Z prices $41,015, while it does devoid of the restricted-slip differential, upgraded brakes, and sportier suspension tune of the Effectiveness model. The Supra begins at $43,450, on the other hand, which is with four-cylinder electricity. Our Z tester was a $54,015 2023 “Proto” spec, mechanically equivalent to the General performance but with gold wheels and yellow interior accents. The Supra was a 2022 Top quality model retailing for $57,355.)

Option of venue was evident, much too. Lime Rock Park is one particular of America’s excellent highway classes, quick, flowing, and surrounded by magnificent place roads that would give us the option to totally examination each car. Lime Rock is also a person of the tracks the place the original Datsun Z produced its mark, earning a popularity as one of the very best sporting activities vehicles on sale in America. Driving a car that evokes the 240Z, channeling legends like Bob Sharp, Sam Posey, Paul Newman, and quite a few other folks, was irresistible.

Did another person say one thing about nostalgia?

DW Burnett

Nissan Z on Observe

The Z exudes standard sports-automobile allure. This new model rides on the similar chassis as the 370Z, by itself an update of the 350Z that entered output 20 many years back, Therefore, it feels previous, but in a great way.

Although not an out-and-out monitor car, the Z was a joy all over Lime Rock, and impressively quick. Editor-at-Huge Travis Okulski was on hand to set lap times, and we followed our usual treatment the place each and every vehicle bought a handful of warm laps. The thought is not to get the fastest time possible, but to show how approachable a car or truck is. The Z posted a 1:02.603 in its 3rd traveling lap about the “vintage” 1.5-mile layout of the circuit. A really respectable time, and 1 that wasn’t complicated to achieve, thanks to its balanced chassis, security below braking, and communicative controls. Okulski stated the Z drives like a big Miata and everybody else agreed. There’s a reasonable bit of body roll in cornering, however the car in no way feels like it is overworking the tires. That roll, combined with effectively-weighted steering—and a good steering wheel—give the driver a tangible perception of connection. Okulski famous some mid-corner understeer in Lime Rock’s very long first convert, Significant Bend, however it can be managed with a slight carry of the throttle. It is really all splendidly cohesive, the rear faithfully following the front, offering the driver a ton of confidence.

Nissan equipped our tester with NISMO brake pads, which will be obtainable at sellers for $450 a established. The brakes have been a emphasize, providing fade-totally free effectiveness during our monitor time. Pedal feel was great, much too, with a minimal bit of “sneeze component” at the leading of the travel, and quick modulation. These are fantastic traits for Lime Rock, which has only 1 major brake zone, at the close of the front straight, where by the Z was hitting all-around 125 mph, and a number of spots exactly where a dab of brake is needed to scrub off speed. The only caveats below are that the pads are really pricey and make an remarkable total of dust.

2023 nissan z performance and 2022 toyota supra

DW Burnett

The Z returns to turbocharging for the initially time since the demise of the Z32 300ZX in 2000, borrowing a 3.-liter unit from Infiniti. When you to start with get on throttle, you can find a little bit of lag, followed by the two turbochargers spooling up really progressively and delivering linear supply to a minor more than 6000 rpm. (Peak electric power is obtained at 6400 rpm, but torque drops off above 5200 rpm.) All round, it is a very good engine, if not totally unique, and it presents the Z really serious speed.

Our tester was geared up with a handbook, and we couldn’t be a lot more delighted. Properly, we could. The gates aren’t as exactly outlined as we might like, and equally Okulski and I concerned about accidental 5-2 downshifts braking into flip one particular. I discovered the pedals to be effectively-spaced for heel-and-toe, while Okulski—who has excessively very long legs—didn’t. It truly is rather of a moot position, for the reason that the transmission comes with vehicle rev-matching—something Nissan pioneered—which functions intuitively. A brief-change package would assistance the feel right here. We held coming again to two words and phrases: “partaking” and “fun.” The Z is a excellent sports car, basic and straightforward, a reminder of why we fell in enjoy with sports activities cars and trucks in the initial put. For the dollars, a Camaro SS 1LE is potentially a far better observe auto, but for someone who generally drives on the road and does just one or two track times a yr, the Z is just about excellent.

Toyota Supra on Monitor

Notably, “partaking” or “enjoyment” were being not text utilized to explain the Supra. Rapid? Certainly. It beat the Z with a 1:02.151 and we’re self-assured it could’ve gone even faster (a Supra test we did in 2019 for an all-out lap time noticed a person flip a 1:01.51 at Lime Rock). Thank the Supra’s Michelin Pilot Super Athletics, which are excellent to the Z’s Bridgestone S007s, the 8-pace computerized in this exam motor vehicle, and a better roll stiffness. Unfortunately, we’re however about a month out from testing the new, manual Supra, earning this a a bit lopsided combat.

The working experience basically is not as satisfying. Velocity will come a great deal simpler in the Supra, nevertheless you will find a nagging sense that the car or truck is much more eager to chunk you. The rear conclude is much much too smooth, wandering beneath braking, battling with the prodigious output of the BMW straight-six, and commonly unable to preserve up with the pretty sharp front finish. Unlike with the Z, the place you at times have to consider about the fronts washing out, the Supra necessitates target on the rear.

It can be not all bad, of program. The motor is the highlight, considerably smoother than the Z’s V-6 and with considerably better throttle reaction in spite of only acquiring one turbo. You will find a lot extra low-finish torque, much too, and the straight-six pulls more durable to its 7000-rpm redline. Most of the time, the ZF eight-pace computerized will work as seamlessly as you would expect, nevertheless Okulski and Digital Director Aaron Brown discovered that it occasionally denied downshifts.

Apparently, we all felt the Supra wouldn’t be as partaking as the Z even if it had a handbook. At the very least not devoid of some meaningful chassis tweaks. The Toyota holds you at arm’s size, with dead steering, and not significantly much more come to feel by means of the seat of your pants both. It truly is a lot quicker in fingers of all practical experience levels, just not enjoyable.

“The Supra feels like a newer auto,” Okulski stated. “Which is to say, it has all the negative characteristics of new cars and trucks and all the fantastic attributes. It really is got a faster gearbox, a considerably much better, extra responsive motor, improved tires, a far more related front end, and it also feels like it was constructed only in pursuit of lap moments, not producing the driver truly feel included in the procedure.”

On the Road

Out on the road, it was a identical story. The Z’s playfulness stood out, and the softer set up started out to make even far more feeling. It breathes far better with the street and engages at decrease speeds, even if it is very easily able of pace that could charitably be explained as “extralegal.” Outside the house the keep track of, in the attractive countryside at Connecticut’s north westerly border with New York, the Z feels at property. At road speeds, the turbo lag and the relative imprecision of the gearbox develop into much less apparent. It is, even so, noticeable that the Z is a significantly more mature car inside of, with a ton of inexpensive switchgear carried in excess of from the 370Z and other Nissan goods. It truly is a essential evil, as Nissan would not have the advancement spending budget to make a sporting activities automobile from the ground up. It’s also effortlessly forgivable because the crucial stuff—seats, steering wheel, transmission, pedals—is all lovely. The gauge cluster is in particular excellent and gimmick-cost-free, with a wonderful significant tach in the center and legible gauges for temperatures and pressures. Exactly what you want in a athletics auto. Bonus details go to the three auxiliary gauges on the dashboard, the greatest of which is the very uncommon turbo pace sensor, a knock-on benefit of Nissan’s use of pace sensors on the turbine shafts.

The Supra’s BMW roots are evident in the cabin, and it feels considerably additional magnificent than the Z. You will find a slickness and polish Nissan only won’t be able to match. In some strategies, the Supra is the far better everyday driver, the preferable car or truck to be in when you might be puttering about town, clicking off miles on the highway, sitting down in targeted traffic, listening to a podcast. Yet, when you might be striving to have entertaining, the Supra doesn’t provide. It’s a automobile that leaves the driver sensation chilly and distant, and the suspension tuning is just not ideal. That rear conclude skips more than bumps and imperfections, and it’s substantially tougher to get into a move with the street surface beneath.

In a best earth, you would have the Z’s chassis and breathtaking exterior and the Supra’s motor and interior. We never reside in a ideal globe, so the Z stays the best selection. Immediately after all, this is a sporting activities vehicle. We don’t buy sports activities vehicles on interior trim we invest in them for the joy they deliver to our lives.

Which delivers us again neatly to nostalgia. In much much more than just seems to be, the Z evokes the spirit of the sports activities car or truck greats, its predecessors among them. It is fun for fun’s sake, the scarce contemporary car or truck that certainly engages the senses like a typical.

It can be a thing of a triumph from Nissan. Its track report over the previous handful of many years has been lackluster. We were being prepared for disappointment, but the Z lives up to its assure. It really is 1 of the most effective Nissans since the GT-R. Irrespective of staying made with theoretically much better, additional fashionable components, the Supra’s complete is fewer than the sum. I might like to imagine you will find a excellent athletics automobile in there someplace, and perhaps the 2023 edition will be specifically that. For now, if you want a great Toyota-badged athletics vehicle, acquire a GR86.

For the nostalgia obsessed, the alternative is noticeable.