From changing filters and drive belts to replacing oil, anodes and impellers, Ali Wood gets some top tips from Stu and Laura Davies on servicing the Project Boat diesel engine
It was time to service the marine diesel engine on our Maxi 84 cruiser. Knowing how to diagnose and ﬁx engine faults is a useful skill for any boat owner, but of course, prevention is even better.
Now that Maximus’s hull was painted, topsides polished and seacocks replaced, our 44-year-old Project Boat was looking good. The mast was wired, leaks fixed and thru-hulls fitted. It was nearly time for launch… but the one job left was giving me sleepless nights: servicing the Volvo Penta MD2020 saildrive.
Laid up engine
For two years, the 43-year-old cruiser had been languishing in a Chichester boatyard and it was anyone’s guess what shape the engine was in. There was, however, a glimmer of hope. The day following the survey we’d asked Dell Quay Marine to jump-start the engine (the batteries having been flat when we viewed her).
It started first time. Also, the previous owner, Daniel Kirtley, who kindly donated the boat, had been meticulous with servicing. Any faults with the engine wouldn’t be through neglect, but just time spent inactive during lockdown.
Boat engine expert Stu Davies
I called PBO’s engine expert, Stu Davies, and asked him if he wanted to do the service. He didn’t hesitate, and drove five hours from North Wales with his wife, Laura.
Stu used to work for oil companies in Africa and the Middle East. If he couldn’t fix the engines, then nobody could. “I’m used to making things work in difficult circumstances,” he said. Hopefully Maximus would be straightforward.
Laura and Stu work as a team. With her slim fingers, Laura’s a whizz at getting into part of the engine no-one else can reach and, like Stu, has a way of explaining things that make perfect sense.
“I do like fiddling with engines,” says Laura, “and I always think if anything happens when we’re out at sea, it’s good to know what to do to get home.”
How often should you service an engine?
An engine service should be done at around 100 hours, which is approximately a season’s use. Stu’s first impression was that the 2005 engine was in pretty good nick. It was clean and the paint was in good condition.
Tools for servicing a marine diesel engine
The following tools are required to service a marine diesel engine. It’s worth keeping these on board for repairs and maintenance:
- Strap wrench
- Spanners or wrenches
- Adjustable spanner
- Socket set
- Oil change pump
- Wire brushes (various thicknesses for larger/smaller parts)
- Vaseline for O-rings and greasing screws
- Marine 16 fuel additive
- Gloves (it’s dirty work)
Rebranded Perkins engine
Stu took a look at the Volvo MD2020 engine. “This is one of the bulletproof Perkins ones,” he said. “It’s simple, easy to work on and parts are readily available.”
In fact, he’d brought all the servicing parts along, kindly donated by parts4engines.com. There was surface rust on the engine mountings, which was no surprise given that the companionway hatch above it had been leaking.
The rainwater had found its way to the top of the secondary filter, which was rusty, along with the starboard engine mount. However, Laura demonstrated how easily the rust could be removed with a wire brush, and Stu recommended painting it with rust curer and Hammerite.
STEP 1 Fuel tank inspection
Maximus’s 10-gallon tank is a simple square design with an inspection hatch under the starboard aft seat. As Laura got to work undoing the fuel inlet, tank breather pipe and fuel lines, Stu gave me a handy tip. “Lefty loosey, righty tighty,” he said, referring to the screw-type fuel shut-off valve. “Make sure that when you open the valve fully and get to the end, you close it half a turn so the next person that handles it will know whether it’s open or closed and won’t break it.”
This would later turn out to be useful advice when, on the shakedown cruise, the valve vibrated closed, cutting off the fuel supply! The lid was held on by 6mm bolts, with
the thread tapped into the tank. A flexible gasket sealed it to the tank which Stu and Laura were careful not to damage.
It all came apart easily enough, and Stu demonstrated how the fuel gauge worked via a float that goes up and down. He pointed out the pickup pipe – what’s known as a stack pipe – which ensures fuel is taken from the bottom of the tank.
I remembered learning the same thing about the PBO pool car when I accidentally put petrol in the diesel tank and drove 30 miles. Fortunately, the stack pipe saved my bacon – it must have drawn the remaining diesel from the bottom of the tank and fortunately the garage was able to siphon out the petrol at the top before it did any damage.
The fuel system
Next, Stu explained how the fuel is fed from the tank to the engine and the excess fuel returned.
“A lot of people don’t realise that the fuel filters are actually polishers,” said Stu. “The fuel goes through the pump to the injectors and unused fuel goes back to the tank so is actually cleaned every time you use it.”
Remnants of old diesel bug
Stu got out his torch ready to inspect the fuel. “Diesel bug grows on the interface between water and diesel,” he said. “You can see sometimes where the condensation has trickled down the inlet pipe, gone into the tank and run to the lowest part.”
Our surveyor, Ben Sutcliffe-Davies had warned there might be diesel bug, so I held my breath, hoping there wouldn’t be any evidence of it. Fortunately the stack pipe and return pipe to and from the engine were spotless – that was good news – but there were clear black marks on the side of the tank where the dreaded bug had been.
Stu concluded that this was the remnants of dead bug – or microbial contamination – but nothing to worry about now. He shone an LED torch through the fuel, which was red diesel, and appeared nice and clear.
“The diesel’s been in the tank for two years and I can’t see any water in there. That’s the culmination of previous years. I don’t think the bug’s live, or that it will make any difference to what you’re going to do,” he said.
I asked Stu about filling the tank to the top, to prevent the opportunity for diesel bug to grow. While he said it was a good idea, he said he checks his tank every
five years, and had never done it himself nor had any problems.
The fuel is clean. Dose it heavily with Marine 16 to prevent diesel bug growth and at some point in the future remove the tank and steam clean the inside of it.
STEP 2 Primary fuel filter change
To my surprise the next thing Stu pulled out of his bag of tricks was a nappy. Well that, at least, was something I knew how to use! Together with an absorbent puppy pad, this was placed beneath the filter to collect fuel spills.
Stu and Laura kept a very neat work area, I noticed, always cleaning up after stages, brushing away rust and wiping down parts.
Locating the primary fuel filter
The primary fuel filter was mounted on the starboard side panel of the engine compartment. Stu showed me the CAV 296 primary fuel filter, a 5 micron filter, which is the first line of defence against dirty fuel. This would replace the current filter. Lower down in the engine was the secondary (fine fuel) filter and the oil filter.
There’s a glass sediment bowl at the bottom of the primary filter to catch any water or dirt filtered out of the diesel fuel. This appeared to be clean.
Using an 11mm spanner Stu set about removing the filter. I watched, trying my best to film it as Stu undid the bolt threaded from the top.
How anyone could do that in a rolling sea, I’ve no idea. I felt seasick just watching him, as the fumes from the spilt diesel (expertly caught in a milk carton) entered my nose.
Removing the primary fuel filter
Stu removed the top half of the filter while Laura held the glass bowl. The clean state of the fuel filter confirmed Stu’s diagnosis that the fuel itself was clean.
“If there’s any water in the system it ends up here,” said Stu. “You can see there’s no water in there, the system is good. In the bottom of these filters there’s a little plastic drain, but I hate using it because if this plastic bit breaks you have to dig all the plastic bits out.”
Another problem with the three-element primary filter (with the glass bowl) is that the replacement never seems to come with enough seals.
There are seals between the glass base, filter and bottom housing. Using Vaseline to hold the seal in place while the combination was mounted, Stu changed the seal that fits on top, and the one where the filter goes, but had to re-use the existing final one on the glass bowl.
Don’t forget to replace the seals
Furthermore, the fixed aluminium housing contained two neoprene seals, one small one that fits on the ‘spigot that the filter pushes onto and one large one that fits in a groove in the housing.
To an observer, these were very difficult to see, but not to be missed, warned Stu. Failure to replace them could result in it leaking air and the engine not starting.
As well as ensuring the seals stay in place during assembly, the three elements themselves have to be in line to get the screw through. What a fiddly job!
If it’s any consolation, Stu admitted it was ‘the worst job of all’. Invariably, when the filter gets blocked it’s in the middle of a big, heavy sea!
“Imagine trying to do this with a boat going up and down,” he said.
Primary filter verdict
A fiddly and messy job. Be sure to have your nappy absorbent pad, and half an empty milk carton, take care with seals and don’t forget the Vaseline. Do it in port whenever possible.
STEP 3 Replacing the secondary fuel filter
We moved on to the secondary filter. This had its own problems, being downright stubborn, and refusing to budge.
With a lot of heaving and grunting Stu managed to free it off with a filter strap wrench – a very useful piece of kit. Again this filter was clean, indicating that the engine had received regular servicing. Stu screwed the new one in by hand until it was just tight.
Secondary fuel filter verdict
Nice and clean, and easier to replace than the primary fuel filter, but don’t forget the filter strap wrench.
STEP 4 Testing the new filters
Before going any further with the engine service, the fuel system needed bleeding of air and Stu needed to test there were no air leaks in the filters.
To do this, Laura used a Pela-type vacuum pump – commonly used for oil changes – to suck fuel through the primary filter to the secondary filter.
This was a quicker option than relying on the engine lift pump.
“If we try to use the lift pump on one of these 2020 engines the capacity is not very good,” said Stu.
“It’s very difficult to pump a large amount of fuel through because the primary fuel filter holds about half a litre. To pump that amount will take forever.”
Removing the bleed plug
Stu removed the bleed plug on the secondary filter, made up a fitting for the orifice with some electrical tape and a few strokes of the pump soon had fuel flowing through the filters. “It’s lovely, that!” exclaimed Stu. “Basically the idea is that any dirt hits the primary filter before it gets any further. On my engine I change my primary filter every year and the secondary filter every two years because the first one protects the second.”
STEP 5 Oil filter change
The oil filter is a spin-on one, mounted horizontally, and again Stu used the filter strap wrench to remove it. The new one was attached and tightened by hand.
“A smear of new oil on the sealing ring is helpful here,” advised Stu. “If the filter was mounted vertically I’d fill it with oil first but as it’s horizontal it is mounted empty.”
The engine takes 2.8lt of oil. The idea is that you put that amount in, start the engine briefly and then check the level. The filter takes up a small amount so the oil level may then need topping up.
Oil filter verdict
You’ll need a filter strap wrench to free this, but is otherwise a simple job as long as you have access.
STEP 6 Engine oil change
Stu seemed surprised when I asked why we were changing the oil. If the fuel could be re-used after two years’ sitting in the tank, why not the oil, I wondered.
“You change the oil as a matter of course,” he said, “normally every 100 hours, or a season’s use.”
When to change engine oil
He explained that oil can absorb acidic products from the combustion process. The perceived wisdom is to change it before the winter layup but he’s left his oil in over winter with no obvious downside. Stu’s engine is now 21 years old and after 3,200 hours is still going strong.
Back in the 1990s when this type of engine was developed the specification for the oil was a straight mineral oil, API CD, and these days a good 15/40 mineral oil will do. Semi-synthetic and synthetic oil is not recommended. For this service, we used Hypalube Plus.
Stu showed me the oil filler cap. “When you take it off you see the valve mechanism,” he said. “If there’s water in the oil you’ll see a white emulsion.”
Fortunately it was clean, so there was no water or condensation in the engine.
Draining the oil from the engine
The oil was drained from the starboard side of the engine through a designated pipe using the suction pump.
If possible, it’s a good idea to warm up the engine first to thin the oil, making the suction easier. However, with Maximus
on the hard-standing this wasn’t an option for us.
On Volvo Penta engines there’s a plastic cap on the oil pipe which needs to be pulled off. Stu made a rubber crossover to get the suction pump pipe to fit.
I’m pleased to say the oil came out easily and was relatively clean, again indicating a good servicing regime.
Stu used a cut down oil container as a funnel to refill the engine with new oil. He then checked the level with the dipstick.
Oil verdict: The oil was clean but replaced as a matter of course.
STEP 7 Raw water impeller change
Raw water is drawn up to the engine by a pump impeller. Driven by a belt, the impeller rotates inside a chamber whose circular shape is distorted inwards, creating a partial vacuum to draw water in.
Speedseal conversion to access impeller
Stu was pleased to see the engine had a Speedseal conversion, allowing easy access to the impeller. This neat, shiny little piece of kit makes the replacement of the impeller a doddle. With the Speedseal, the six original screws have been replaced with four knurled knobs which can be undone by hand, with the bottom two left in-situ so the impeller cover can simply be slipped upwards. The seal is an O-ring, so it does away with the necessity of a fiddly paper gasket.
Inside there’s a Teflon bearing with a bronze washer which allows the pump to be run dry for a short time without damaging the impeller.
For this reason Speedseals are popular with the RNLI and military, Stu explained, but sadly the company that made them has ceased trading and new O-rings and parts for them are becoming scarce.
Removing the impeller
After the Speedseal cover was taken off Laura removed the impeller with pliers so gently she reminded me of a nurse removing a foreign object from a child’s nostril! She gripped each impeller blade alternately so the whole lot gradually worked free.
Stu showed me the cracks and misshapen blades on the old impeller, where it had worn away. That said, it wasn’t in too bad a condition with some setting of the blades caused by it being in one position for two years without running. It would still serve as a decent spare, but it was definitely time for a new one.
How the impeller works
“The impeller blade picks up a slug of water, and straightens, bends, straightens, bends as the water goes past the lobe,” explained Stu. “Over time the lobes wear and it loses its efficiency. A new impeller usually fixes everything, but if it doesn’t, occasionally – if you see water coming out of the back of the pump – you have to remove the pump and replace the seal.”
The seawater pump for this engine is either a Jabsco or a Johnson depending on the year of manufacture. If you give the model number to Parts4Engines they’ll send the correct information.
Laura carefully cleaned the bronze housing and cover with a wire brush and slathered everything with the lubricant supplied with the impeller. Again, the O-ring was cleaned and held in place with Vaseline and the impeller put back with the drive pin through the centre, positioned to slide into the drive slot on the shaft in the pump. The blades were carefully bent to one side to enable it to enter the pump.
Stu turned over the engine by hand to make sure the blades were orientated the correct way before replacing the cover.
Slightly worn, with misshapen blades, this needed to be replaced, but can be saved as a spare.
STEP 8 Check the antifreeze
Stu pointed out where the fresh water coolant is topped up. The cap came off easily and we checked the level, which was about half an inch below – a good sign.
“The antifreeze level looks good and it’s green. Normally, when it starts getting exhausted it changes colour. Leave it for now, and then in the winter change the coolant.”
The term ‘antifreeze’ is a misnomer. As well as guarding against frost damage, it contains rust and corrosion inhibitors that help protect the insides of the engine. ‘Antifreeze’ effectiveness is reduced over time, hence the need for the coolant to be replaced annually, regardless of any risk of freezing.
Coolant looks good but will need replacing over winter.
STEP 9 Alternator drive belt
The alternator charges the boat’s batteries when the engine is running. It’s a compact device in which a magnetised rotor spins within a magnetic field, the spinning being done by a V-belt from a pulley on the front of the engine.
The alternator fitted to the MD2020 is usually a 60Ah Valeo alternator, which is more than ample to keep up with the loads of a small boat such as the Maxi 84.
Removing the alternator drive belt
The alternator was attached to the engine with a 17mm bolt at the pivot with the adjustment by two 13mm bolts. Stu slackened these and swung the alternator towards the engine so the old belt could be removed.
“Not a lot of people realise this but alternator belts drive on the sides of the ‘V’, not the bottom,” explained Stu. He showed me the worn belt and the replacement. “You can see how wide this tooth is compared to the old one, which is very badly worn.”
How can you tell when the alternator belt is worn?
The friction to transmit the power to generate electricity is between the sides of the V on the belt and the V of the pulleys. When the belt is worn, it ‘bottoms out’, meaning there’s less surface area to drive the alternator and so the pulleys slip, wear the belt more and it makes things worse.
“Tightening it at this point is useless,” concluded Stu. “It needs to be replaced. A sign that things are bad is when you find black dust all around the area of the alternator from the worn belt.”
Unfortunately, there was plenty of evidence of this on Maximus’s engine.
Stu pointed out another complication here being that the rainwater leak had superficially rusted the pulleys.
Fitting a new alternator V-belt
Laura cleaned the pulleys with a wire brush to remove the surface rust. The new V-belt was fitted and the alternator tensioned using the handle of a hammer as a lever before the bolts were tightened.
“Hear that sound?” asked Stu, twanging the belt with about ½in of play at the longest point.
I’d have to remember that sound for some homework later. Stu advised that after an hour’s running time it would slacken a bit, so I must re-tension it as the belt beds itself beds in.
Alternator belt verdict
A new V-belt was needed as the old one was badly worn. Don’t forget to re-tension after an hour or so of running.
STEP 10 Checking the seawater strainer
Maximus is an intercooled engine. Most stern and saildrive engines take in seawater or ‘raw’ water through a valve in the leg. This is sucked through a coarse filter, or ‘strainer’ to prevent waterborn debris getting as far as the water pump.
From the pump the water goes into the antisyphon valve at the back and from there through the filter into the intercooler.
If you get any weed or rubbish, it ends up in the strainer, and that’s what we found when Stu took it off.
Raw water strainer verdict
Lift this out occasionally and clean out the weed.
STEP 11 Checking the sail drive oil level
Maximus’s engine has a saildrive. Unlike sterndrives, where the engine’s mounted at the stern, the saildrive leg can’t be steered or tilted. It passes through a strong rubber diaphragm that isolates the engine vibrations from the hull while keeping water at bay.
The saildrive, which has a folding prop, is bolted to the back of the engine and in the Maxi is tricky to reach. Thanks to Laura’s slim hands, we managed to access a red oil filler T-screw, which was removed to show a good level of clean mineral oil. We therefore left it as it was.
How much oil for a saildrive?
The recommended saildrive oil varies with the engine’s year of manufacture. For some, Volvo Penta specify ATF (automatic transmission fluid), while for others it’s mineral oil. There appeared to be mineral oil in this one.
At the side of this filler cap there was a stack pipe with a knurled knob pushed into it. Stu deduced that this was the access to allow sucking-out of the oil when it needed changing.
When inspecting the engine during the survey, Ben Sutcliffe-Davies, had mentioned that the raw water inlet pipe disappeared under the engine but he couldn’t access the valve. We followed the pipe from the raw water strainer andfound it went to a ball valve which was screwed into the sail drive leg.
Laura cycled it for a while to make sure all was good.
Saildrive oil verdict
The oil level was good. Mineral oil required for the MD2020.
STEP 12 Checking the saildrive anodes
Also during the boat survey, Ben had noticed the anodes on the outside of the saildrive hadn’t been electrically connected to the leg, so we decided to change them. What should have been a simple job turned out to be a mammoth effort involving myself – but mostly Stu and Laura – taking it in turns to drill the seized stainless steel bolt out! We’d certainly earned our tea and biscuits after that.
I didn’t have the right prop anode, but ordered a set which my husband fitted the following week.
Antifouling the saildrive
“One other point,” Stu added. “The saildrive is made of aluminium. Don’t use copper-based antifouling on aluminium because they react together so you need some special antifouling for that leg.”
Just as well that Seajet – who provided our Bioclean antifouling – had also supplied some of their Pellerclean.
A seized anode can be a monster to get off!
Other things to note
There were a few other things Stu pointed out that were useful to know. The exhaust pipe was loose and needed strapping down. He also pointed out that the raw water strainer needed some new penny washers to secure it properly.
I was pleased to see there was a mechanical means of stopping the engine if the control panel failed. It seemed fairly easy to access – you just pull it and the engine stops. Similarly, there’s a throttle on the engine so you can manually operate it when not in the cockpit.
I asked Stu if he’d ever come across a runaway engine situation. He said he hadn’t but occasionally, on engines with electrical solenoids operating the stop lever, the solenoids can fail.
Time to start the engine
Finally the big start! How would the engine perform after two years on the hard standing? We couldn’t start the engine in the ordinary way, being on dry land, so Stu poured fresh water directly into the seawater strainer from a 5-gallon drum.
In this instance, we didn’t need the seawater intake so we checked the seacock was closed. The engine seacock on Maximus is surprisingly hard to find. Since the engine service I must have turned it on and off 20 times, but I still struggle to find it! It involves me leaning right into the engine compartment (making sure loose hair is tied up) and reaching right down the back of it in search of the smooth red, metal lever. It’s easier to find when switched off because it’s at right angles to the inlet pipe.
Know where the seacocks are
Understanding where the seacocks are is essential for all the crew, and this reminded me to allow extra time in future when on other people’s boats to find the engine seacock. Hopefully it won’t be as difficult to reach as this one!
The electrician had left a nicely charged 80Ah battery for us which Stu connected. Laura turned the key on the start panel and it all lit up OK. She waited until the heating or glow plugs lit up for 30 secs and then turned the key all the way.
The engine started first time! What a pleasing noise. I checked the back of the boat and saw the water running out of the exhaust. The cooling water was pumping OK, and with the charge light out, we ran it for a minute or two until the drum of water ran out.
It was the outcome we’d all hoped for. Finally, Maximus was ready to launch!
Top tips for servicing your engine
- Cut the top off a milk carton and wrap it under the fuel filter so you can catch fuel spills
- A nappy helps collect excess oil and diesel. Absorbent pads are great for keeping a clean work area
- Use grease or Vaseline to hold a seal or O-ring in place
- Dip screws in Vaseline before screwing back in to keep them lubricated
- A foam covering for the air intake quietens the engine. You can buy them from car shops.
- Rust often looks worse than it is. It’s surprising what a wire brush can do
- A torch is handy for looking into the dark recesses of an engine. A head torch is good as it leaves your hands free
- Every yacht should have a Swiss Army knife – perfect for many jobs
- Write the installation date on the filters to remind you when they need changing
- Wonder Wipes help keep a workstation clean
The now-hot seawater, on the other hand, is pumped into the exhaust system and used to cool the exhaust gases on its way out. That’s why we check for water in the exhaust, and it also explains why you can hear the ‘bloop, bloop, woosh’ noise of a boat going past; what’s happening is that the seawater is building up in the silencer and the pressure of the exhaust is collecting it and blowing it out.
The Volvo Penta MD2020 started off as a Perkins engine, so Perkins parts fit and are generally cheaper to source than Volvo spares. Stu Davies recommends people carry a spare oil filter, fuel filters, alternator belt, anodes and a water pump impeller as minimum.
The CAV 296 primary filter is very commonly used all over the world. Stu carries three or four of these, because if you ever get a problem with water in the fuel, this is what you change first. Have a couple of secondary fuel filters available too, and while oil filters tend to only need changing once a year, it’s still a good idea to have a spare.