3 myths about electric cars

3 myths about electric cars

Issued on: Modified:

Paris (AFP) – Sceptics say that significantly from supporting save the planet, electric powered automobiles are a liberal pipe-dream whose environmental benefits are exaggerated.

But even if there is no these matter as an all-eco-friendly vehicle, experiments display that battery-powered kinds result in much less destructive greenhouse gasoline all round than their petrol-pushed ancestors.

AFP Truth Verify examined a few popular claims about them.


“Coal Driven Electrical Automobiles…. Assisting liberals fake they are resolving a make-consider disaster,” reads a text shared on Facebook, with a photograph of autos plugged in at a charging station.

The humorous meme implies that electric powered cars and trucks do not help lower local weather-modifying greenhouse fuel emissions for the reason that coal is burned to feed the electrical power grid.

The US Environmental Protection Company has a calculator tool on its web page to examine a petrol car’s emissions with all those of an electrical 1 relying on exactly where it is charged.

It calculates that an electric powered automobile billed in St Louis, Missouri -– element of the subregion that depends the most on coal –- on typical will create 247 grams of carbon dioxide for every mile, reduce than the typical 381 grams of a gasoline car or truck.

An electric car's carbon impact varies depending on where it is charged
An electric car’s carbon effects differs based on where it is billed Patrick Meinhardt AFP

Industry experts at Carbon Temporary agree an electric car’s emissions rely on what location or country it is billed in.

They would be larger in Poland or in an Asian nation where additional coal is burned than in France, wherever most electric power arrives from nuclear electricity.

All round, the Intercontinental Council on Clean up Transportation (ICCT) identified electrical cars are lessen-emitting than their petrol-driven equivalents across their everyday living cycle, from mining parts to recycling.

An electrical car or truck is also considerably a lot more effective in its use of energy than a petrol-run a person, according to the US Section of Energy and other sources.

‘200 tonnes of earth’

Producing the vehicles’ batteries is an power-intense procedure that involves mining and trucking uncooked materials, assembly in factories, and shipping and delivery worldwide. Recycling them is expensive.

Another viral textual content shared on Fb claimed that 500,000 lbs (227 metric tonnes) of earth are dug up to extract the metals for a person electric powered automobile battery.

The estimate appeared to originate from a 2020 evaluation by the Manhattan Institute, a local weather-sceptic study team.

Various specialists consulted by AFP stated the figures had been misleading. Peter Newman, professor of sustainability at Australia’s Curtin University, judged it a “gross exaggeration” and stated the amount mined would change relying on geography and the sort of battery.

Mining has other impacts not quickly related to the global climate. About 70 {09e594db938380acbda72fd0ffbcd1ef1c99380160786adb3aba3c50c4545157} of cobalt — a battery ingredient — comes from the Democratic Republic of Congo, exactly where use of youngster labour in mines has been documented.

A child and a woman breaking rocks extracted from a cobalt mine in Lubumbashi, DR Congo, in 2016
A little one and a female breaking rocks extracted from a cobalt mine in Lubumbashi, DR Congo, in 2016 JUNIOR KANNAH AFP

Accessibility to the components also raises strategic offer problems, with a lot of of the raw components held by China, according to the International Power Agency.

Georg Bieker, a Berlin-centered researcher at the ICCT, stated the environmental hurt from oil-drilling built gasoline production no greater.

The chance of devastation pushed by greenhouse gas emissions, projected in current reports by the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Local weather Transform, would be even worse.

“It is proper to desire enhancements, e.g. as regarded by voluntary standards in the business and by necessary because of diligence demands that are foreseen in the upcoming EU battery regulation,” he reported.

“In any situation, it’s distinct that the social and environmental influence of world warming is catastrophic, at a different scale than the mining of battery uncooked products.”

‘Stuck in snow’

Soon after a snowstorm stranded hundreds of motorists in Virginia in January, people on Fb shared posts warning that electric cars would operate out of ability and make the traffic jam even even worse.

“All people men and women would be caught in freezing temperatures without having a heated car. And all the vehicles would be stuck unable to transfer mainly because you are not able to provide a charging station to them,” browse the text.

“All these electric powered vehicles would develop into roadblocks to the gasoline driven motor vehicles.”

Various fact-checking organisations scrutinised the claim. They discovered there was no proof that electric powered cars and trucks would fare even worse in a storm.

Research this sort of as one posted in 2015 by the American Chemical Society have observed that electric vehicles do eat electrical power significantly less successfully when driving in the chilly.

Some people raised questions about how electric vehicles would fare when stuck in a traffic jam in the snow
Some people elevated concerns about how electrical vehicles would fare when stuck in a targeted visitors jam in the snow Angela Weiss AFP

However many specialists mentioned that if trapped in a storm, an electric auto would take in fewer electric power than a gasoline one, which would have to preserve its engine functioning to electricity the heating.

British buyer affairs magazine Which? examined an electrical SUV by simulating a targeted traffic jam, with the car’s radio, air conditioning, seat-heating and headlights on, moreover a tablet system plugged in enjoying a movie.

That utilised up a negligible two percent of the battery, or eight miles’ worth of range, in an hour and a quarter – admittedly in summertime problems.